Year: 1998
Location: Clearwater, Florida – Existing Clearwater Shopping Mall
Size: 72.5 Acres, +/- 900,000 Square Feet
Status: Completed; 25+ years in operation
Role: James Easton, AIA, NCARB, project designer / planner
Firm: Tyndall Associates Architects, Joe Tyndall, AIA, Architect

Significance: From Mall to Market: The evolution of Retail Development in Florida

Clearwater Mall Redevelopment – 1998

Clearwater, Florida – Retail Master Planning

By the late 1990s, retail development in Florida was at a turning point. Conventional strip centers and enclosed malls still dominated the landscape, but the limitations of those models—particularly in warm, coastal climates—were becoming increasingly clear. While efficient from a leasing standpoint, these environments often lacked identity, pedestrian engagement, and long-term adaptability.

In 1997–1998, a conceptual retail and entertainment development for Clearwater, Florida explored an alternative approach. The project emerged during a transitional moment in the industry and was informed by team members with prior experience on major destination retail environments, including early urban entertainment districts and large-scale regional malls. That background introduced a broader set of ideas to what might otherwise have followed a conventional power center model.

The client, Ed Kobel of DeBartolo Development, represented a generation of retail development operating at a national scale. Projects of this type were not isolated efforts—they were part of a larger shift in how retail environments were conceived, financed, and delivered across the United States. The Clearwater concept sits within that context, bridging established power center planning with emerging ideas around mixed-use and experiential retail.

At the core of the design was a rethinking of circulation. Rather than organizing the site strictly around parking fields and tenant pads, the plan introduced internal streets, gathering spaces, and layered pedestrian movement. Retail, dining, and entertainment were arranged to create a sequence of spaces rather than a collection of disconnected storefronts, allowing the site to be experienced as an environment rather than a single destination.

The program reflected this hybrid approach. Large-format anchors—typical of power center development—were combined with smaller retail pads, restaurants, and an entertainment component, including a theater. The intent was to create a destination capable of functioning throughout the day and into the evening, increasing both dwell time and overall economic performance.

Climate response was integral to the design strategy. In Florida, exposure to sun and heat fundamentally shapes how people use space. The project incorporated shaded walkways, covered edges, and landscaped zones to support outdoor circulation. These elements were not applied features, but embedded components of the site organization—an approach that has since become standard in successful open-air retail environments throughout the region.

A significant outcome of the development was the integration of civic infrastructure. As part of the approval process, the city required a new fire station. Rather than treating it as a separate or purely utilitarian element, the design incorporated Clearwater Fire and Rescue Station #49 directly into the site. The station was ultimately constructed and remains in operation, representing a lasting public component within a larger private development.

This integration reflects a broader reality of large-scale development: projects of this size extend beyond retail alone. Infrastructure, access, and public services are often embedded within the planning process, shaping both the project and the surrounding community over time.

The Clearwater plan also illustrates the evolution of retail site planning. While parking remained a dominant factor, the layout began to move away from purely vehicle-oriented organization. Internal circulation, building placement, and tenant mix were used to create a more coherent and adaptable framework, anticipating the transition toward lifestyle centers and mixed-use development that would emerge more fully in the following decade.

Looking back, many of the ideas explored in this project have since become standard practice. Open-air retail, integrated dining and entertainment, pedestrian-oriented planning, and climate-responsive design are now baseline expectations in Florida development. What was once exploratory has become part of the industry’s foundation.

At the same time, the underlying challenges remain consistent. Retail development must continue to respond to climate, durability, maintenance, and long-term adaptability. Projects that perform well are those that balance immediate economic viability with long-term use—something that depends as much on construction and material strategy as it does on planning.

The Clearwater Mall concept represents a moment within that evolution. Developed at the intersection of traditional power center logic and emerging experiential design, it reflects both the constraints of its time and the direction the industry was beginning to move.

For developers working in Florida today, the lessons remain relevant. Successful retail environments are not simply collections of tenants—they are structured systems shaped by climate, movement, and long-term performance.

Return to Retail / Entertainment Design

Return to Home-Page